Calamity Jane - Nice sweet cinnamon/clove scent. Love it!. Nothing to really compare it to.
Fire in the Hole - If you were to be outside camping, the campfire had just gone out and you leaned forward and took a sniff this is what I'd expect it to smell like. Charcoal like campfire scent. I liked it.
Blazing Saddles - This to me was like sticking my nose into a brand new baseball glove and taking a big whiff. Pure clean leather. Nice.
Lust in the Dust - Has a vintage-like perfume scent. I would expect a saloon girl, if you know what I mean to smell like this.
Mountain Hideout - This one is awesome. Close your eyes and you feel like your sitting in an old log cabin in the woods. A musty pine log cabin smell is spot on.
The Gambler - If you walked into a smoky poker room this is what it would smell like. Another winner.
Home on the Range - I was thinking a sweet smell but boy was I wrong. Flowers.......it smells like you're standing in a field "On the Range" blanketed by flowers. Wizzard of Oz like blanket of flowers.
I didn't even finish the milled bars and I aleady bought one each of the hand made soaps for comparison. So far they are all fantastic...all the hand made bars so far that I've tried rate the same as above but the scent is much much stronger. The hand made bars also look great with all the colorful swirls. The handmade "Fire in the Hole" bar literally looks like a fire coming off an ember. Hoow cool is that?
I've tried a few different brands and as of now this is my favorite brand.